Blog Post: Enhancing Urban Resilience Through Data Analytics and Technology

1. Introduction to Urban Resilience

1.1 Definition and Context

Urban resilience refers to the capacity of urban areas to withstand, adapt to, and recover from various disruptions, particularly those related to climate change, natural disasters, and social challenges. It encompasses not only environmental sustainability but also social equity, economic stability, and the overall well-being of city inhabitants. The context for urban resilience has evolved as cities are increasingly affected by unpredictable climate events, such as floods, heatwaves, and hurricanes, necessitating comprehensive and integrated approaches to urban planning and governance. The rise of megacities, along with the growing interconnectedness of global urban systems, has further emphasized the need for resilience strategies that are informed by data and technology, ensuring cities can contend with both chronic stresses and acute shocks.

1.2 Importance of Urban Resilience

The importance of urban resilience lies in its ability to address climate change challenges while enhancing the quality of life for city dwellers. As urban populations continue to rise globally, the demand for sustainable infrastructure, efficient public services, and equitable resource distribution becomes increasingly critical. By fostering resilience, cities can better prepare for climate impacts—such as rising sea levels and extreme weather events—thereby minimizing disruptions to everyday life.

Urban resilience also plays a vital role in enhancing the quality of life for residents. Resilient urban areas tend to have robust public health systems, reliable transportation networks, access to green spaces, and vibrant community structures that foster social cohesion. These features not only mitigate the adverse effects of climate change but also contribute to improved mental health, economic opportunities, and overall social welfare.

The interplay between climate change and urban resilience underscores the need for integrated governance frameworks that prioritize sustainability. It requires collaboration among various stakeholders, including governments, private sectors, and local communities, to leverage data analytics, smart technologies, and innovative design solutions.

In summary, urban resilience is essential not only for minimizing vulnerability to climate impacts but also for fostering thriving urban environments where quality of life is prioritized and sustained.

2. Urban Data Analytics and Climate Resilience

2.1 Definition and Importance

Urban data analytics refers to the systematic collection, analysis, and interpretation of data from urban environments to inform decision-making processes. This field is of utmost importance in bolstering climate resilience, as it provides essential insights into urban dynamics, risks, and resource needs. Through advanced analytical techniques, cities can predict the impacts of climate events, track resource utilization, and assess the effectiveness of resilience measures.

2.2 Key Components

Innovative Data Collection Methods
Cities are leveraging a range of innovative data collection techniques, including remote sensing technologies, Internet of Things (IoT) sensors, and citizen science initiatives. Remote sensing allows for high-resolution satellite imagery to monitor changes in land use, vegetation cover, and urban expansion, while IoT sensors enable real-time monitoring of environmental parameters such as air quality, temperature, and water levels.

Data Analysis and Integration
The integration of various data sources is crucial for effective resilience planning. By combining data from different sectors—such as transportation, public health, and emergency services—planners can develop comprehensive insights that guide investment decisions and policy formulation.

2.3 Recent Trends in Data Analytics

Recent trends highlight the growing role of social innovation and digital technology in enhancing urban resilience. Social media platforms serve as valuable data sources, reflecting community sentiments and behavioral patterns during crisis situations, enabling faster and more responsive urban governance. Additionally, advancements in machine learning and artificial intelligence have made it possible to analyze vast datasets for predictive modeling, allowing city planners to better prepare for potential climate impacts.

2.4 Applications and Implications

Urban data analytics has several applications, including improving decision-making processes, enhancing community engagement, and informing sustainable infrastructure development. By using data to identify at-risk areas and populations, cities can prioritize interventions that have the most significant impact.

2.5 Challenges in Data Integration

Despite its potential, integrating data for urban resilience poses challenges, including interoperability issues, privacy concerns, and ensuring equitable access to data. Establishing standards for data sharing and maintaining robust data governance frameworks are vital in addressing these challenges.

2.6 Case Studies in Urban Resilience

Cities like New York, which dramatically reshaped its urban planning strategies in the aftermath of Hurricane Sandy, demonstrate the effective utilization of data-driven approaches in resilience planning. By incorporating real-time data into resilience strategies, municipalities can optimize resource allocation and response mechanisms during future climate events.

2.7 Related Topics

Key related topics include urban resilience, climate change mitigation, and digital innovation. The synergy between these domains is crucial for establishing holistic approaches to urban challenges, reflecting the interconnected nature of modern urban life.

3. Role of Technology in Enhancing Urban Resilience

3.1 Definition of Key Aspects

Technological advancements play a transformative role in enhancing urban resilience. By incorporating digital tools and smart systems into urban management practices, cities can foster sustainability and social stability.

3.2 Key Components

Digital Economy, Smart Infrastructure, and Biophilic Designs
Embracing a digital economy encourages cities to leverage technology in various sectors—transportation, housing, and public services—ensuring efficient resource distribution. Smart infrastructure integrates adaptive technologies that respond to changing urban dynamics, while biophilic design incorporates nature into urban spaces, promoting ecological resilience.

3.3 Recent Developments in Technology

Emerging technologies, such as digital twins—digital replicas of physical entities—offer new insights into urban systems, allowing cities to simulate outcomes of various scenarios and thus, improving resilience planning. Moreover, implementing heatwave resilience strategies involves using technology to predict and manage heat-related health risks.

3.4 Applications and Implications

The impact of technology extends across decision-making processes, optimal resource utilization, and enhanced community participation. By utilizing platforms that facilitate open data access, cities can empower residents to contribute actively towards resilience initiatives.

3.5 Smart City Initiatives

Cities employing smart solutions—like AI-driven traffic management systems that adapt to environmental conditions—highlight the potential of technology to improve resilience and operational efficiency amid climate challenges.

3.6 Collaboration Between Public and Private Sectors

Collaboration among government agencies, private enterprises, and local groups is essential for deploying resilience technologies effectively. By pooling resources and expertise, stakeholders can enhance their collective impact on urban resilience strategies.

3.7 Emerging Technologies

The potential of emerging technologies such as blockchain, machine learning, and augmented reality (AR) offers exciting prospects for revolutionizing community engagement and decision-making processes. These tools facilitate transparent data sharing, restore trust within communities, and encourage active participation in urban resilience efforts.

3.8 Related Topics

Discussions surrounding sustainability, economic development, and social cohesion are essential as cities aim to create inclusive strategies that prioritize resilience.

4. Data-Driven Decision Making in Urban Planning

4.1 Definition and Context

Data-driven decision-making in urban planning involves systematic use of data to guide the development and implementation of urban policies and projects. It emphasizes the importance of evidence-based approaches in navigating the complexities of urbanization, ensuring that interventions are responsive and grounded in reality.

4.2 Key Components of Data-Driven Urban Planning

Important components include robust data collection methods, urban management functions, and technology integration. Emphasizing collaboration across sectors strengthens the data governance structure that supports effective urban planning.

4.3 Recent Trends

Recent trends underscore the importance of city instrumentation and transdisciplinary approaches that bring together experts from various fields to solve urban challenges collectively.

4.4 Applications and Implications

The applications of data-driven urban planning span improved service delivery, risk modeling, and sustainable urban design. Cities leveraging data to manage services can optimize resource allocations and enhance overall functionality and resilience.

4.5 Impact of Big Data on Urban Policy

The influence of big data on urban policies ranges from reshaping zoning laws to refining transportation planning, showcasing the transformative potential of data-driven governance.

4.6 Tools and Technologies for Data Analysis

Key tools include Geographic Information Systems (GIS), dashboards for real-time data visualization, and predictive analytics. These technologies empower urban planners with actionable insights to respond effectively to changing urban landscapes.

4.7 Community-Driven Data Initiatives

Community-driven data initiatives advocate for the inclusion of local input in shaping urban planning decisions, reinforcing the idea that resilience is achieved through collaboration and community empowerment.

4.8 Related Fields

Relevant fields of inquiry include urban analytics, smart sustainable cities, and data-driven urban research, emphasizing the multi-faceted nature of urban resilience.

5. Conclusion

In conclusion, the integration of data analytics and technology is essential for strengthening urban resilience against climate change. As cities face increasing pressure from environmental challenges, leveraging data-driven tools, fostering technological partnerships, and prioritizing community engagement will be crucial navigational aids. Stakeholders are encouraged to collaborate and innovate, ensuring sustainable and resilient futures for urban populations everywhere.

Urban Data Analytics and Climate Resilience

2.1 Definition and Importance

Urban data analytics refers to the systematic collection, processing, and analysis of data derived from urban environments to inform decision-making and policy development. As cities around the globe face increasing threats from climate change—from rising sea levels and extreme weather events to urban heat islands—the importance of urban data analytics is becoming undeniable. The insights generated through urban data analytics not only help in understanding the vulnerabilities of urban systems but also in crafting strategies for building resilience. By analyzing data from various sources, urban planners and policymakers can anticipate future challenges, optimize resource allocation, and enhance the overall quality of life for city residents.

2.2 Key Components

Innovative Data Collection Methods

The success of urban data analytics hinges on robust data collection methods. This encompasses innovative technologies such as:

• Remote Sensing: Satellites and aerial imagery provide comprehensive data regarding urban land use, green spaces, and environmental conditions. This bird’s-eye view aids in assessing vulnerabilities to climatic events and planning accordingly.

• IoT Sensors: Internet of Things (IoT) sensors can monitor real-time data on air quality, temperature, humidity, and water levels. These sensors contribute to a granular understanding of urban dynamics, enabling rapid response to potential crises.

• Citizen Science: Engaging the community in data collection enriches the data landscape. Platforms that allow citizens to report environmental conditions and participate in local surveys help generate critical information, fostering a sense of ownership and engagement in resilience strategies.

Data Analysis and Integration

Data analysis and integration form the backbone of urban resilience planning. Effective resilience strategies rely on a broad array of data sources—from historical climate data to socio-economic information—integrated into a cohesive framework. By employing advanced analytical techniques, cities can identify patterns, assess risks, and simulate various scenarios for future climatic impacts. This integrative approach helps align urban planning efforts with climate resilience objectives, ensuring that development paths are sustainable and adaptive.

2.3 Recent Trends in Data Analytics

The recent trends in urban data analytics reflect a significant paradigm shift:

• Role of Social Innovation: As urban challenges become increasingly complex, initiatives that harness collective intelligence, community input, and evidence-based strategies are gaining traction. Social innovation fosters a collaborative spirit among residents, NGOs, and local authorities, improving the community’s capacity to address climate-related issues.

• Digital Technology Adoption: Also, the integration of digital technologies, such as machine learning and predictive analytics, streamlines urban data processing, enabling cities to forecast and prepare for climate impacts more efficiently. This trend signifies a growing reliance on data-driven insights to guide urban policy and infrastructure investments.

2.4 Applications and Implications

Data analytics has practical applications with significant implications for urban resilience:

• Decision-Making: Real-time analytics empower decision-makers with actionable insights, facilitating proactive measures against climate stressors. For example, predictive models can guide flood defenses or inform heatwave responses.

• Community Engagement: Through transparent data-sharing practices, community members can become active participants in urban resilience efforts, voicing concerns and collaborating on solutions. This engagement builds trust and cohesion, critical for addressing local climate challenges.

• Sustainable Infrastructure: Empowered by data, urban planners can invest in green infrastructure solutions, such as permeable pavements and urban forests, which mitigate the urban heat island effect and improve stormwater management.

2.5 Challenges in Data Integration

Despite the promise of urban data analytics, several challenges warrant attention:

• Interoperability: Many cities struggle to integrate data from disparate systems, hindering a holistic understanding of urban resilience. The lack of standardization across platforms complicates data sharing and analysis.

• Privacy Concerns: The collection of personal and sensitive data raises ethical concerns. Safeguarding individual privacy while still leveraging community-derived data necessitates robust policies and frameworks that foster trust.

• Equitable Access: Poor or underserved communities often lack access to the technologies and infrastructures that enable effective data collection and utilization. Addressing this digital divide is essential for ensuring equitable resilience planning and outcomes.

2.6 Case Studies in Urban Resilience

Examining specific case studies can enhance our understanding of effective urban resilience strategies:

• New York Post-Hurricane Sandy: After Hurricane Sandy devastated parts of New York City, data analytics played a critical role in post-disaster recovery. Initiatives included comprehensive assessments of vulnerability and the integration of data across different city agencies. This led to improved resource allocation and new policies that prioritized green infrastructure, highlighting adaptive strategies in the face of urban challenges.

2.7 Related Topics

To fully grasp the scope of urban data analytics and its impact on climate resilience, it is essential to consider related topics:

• Urban Resilience: Understanding how cities can withstand and recover from climate impacts is foundational to planning effective strategies.

• Climate Change Mitigation: Integrative efforts in data analytics and resilience inform adaptive practices that can also contribute to broader climate mitigation initiatives, reducing overall greenhouse gas emissions.

• Digital Innovation: Emerging technologies continue to reshape urban analytics, leading to more informed policies and greater community engagement. Cities are increasingly leveraging artificial intelligence, machine learning, and data visualization tools in their resilience frameworks, paving the way for smarter urban environments.

By combining insights from urban analytics, technology, and community engagement, cities can craft more effective, equitable, and sustainable resilience strategies to combat the challenges posed by climate change. This multidimensional approach reflects an understanding of the interconnectedness of various urban systems and the necessity for cooperative action to navigate the uncertainties ahead.

Role of Technology in Enhancing Urban Resilience

3.1 Definition of Key Aspects

Urban resilience refers to the capacity of an urban system to absorb and adapt to disruptions while supporting the essential functions of its infrastructure and community. Key aspects involve the integration of technology, analytics, and community engagement in enhancing responses to environmental shocks like extreme weather, economic fluctuations, or social changes. Technology plays a crucial role in enabling cities to better understand vulnerabilities, coordinate responses, and facilitate recovery processes.

3.2 Key Components

1. Digital Economy:

The digital economy provides foundational infrastructure for integrating technology into urban resilience efforts. It encompasses e-commerce, digital services, and the deployment of smart technologies that can lead to more economically resilient communities. By fostering innovation and entrepreneurship, cities can diversify their economies, making them less susceptible to external shocks.

1. Smart Infrastructure:

Smart urban infrastructure involves the use of embedded sensors, IoT devices, and real-time data analytics to enhance the efficiency and reliability of urban services. This includes smart transportation systems, energy grids, and water management solutions that not only improve operational performance but also increase urban resilience by anticipating and responding to climatic challenges.

1. Biophilic Designs:

Incorporating nature into urban settings (biophilic design) strengthens ecological resilience and enhances the well-being of urban residents. This approach can mitigate heat effects, improve air quality, and foster community connections, all of which are critical for creating green, livable neighborhoods.

3.3 Recent Developments in Technology

Recent advancements in technology have seen the adoption of Digital Twins, which are virtual replicas of physical urban systems. By simulating real-world conditions, municipalities can better understand how environmental changes like heatwaves affect urban dynamics. Enhanced simulations allow for improved planning and more effective heatwave resilience strategies, indicating how cities can respond in real-time to extreme weather events and other emergencies.

3.4 Applications and Implications

Leveraging technological advancements enhances decision-making capabilities by providing urban planners with real-time data to assess potential risks and quickly allocate resources. This improved decision-making leads to innovative resource utilization strategies that optimize existing infrastructure while empowering community involvement through accessible data sharing and participatory planning processes.

3.5 Smart City Initiatives

Smart city initiatives exemplify leveraging technology to manage urban environments more effectively. For instance, AI can optimize traffic management systems during extreme weather, redirecting vehicles away from congested or hazardous areas and improving overall public safety. These initiatives not only enhance operational efficiency but also contribute to reduced carbon footprints and improved air quality.

3.6 Collaboration Between Public and Private Sectors

Collaboration between public entities and private tech companies is essential for enhancing urban resilience planning. These partnerships promote resource sharing, knowledge exchange, and co-development of technology solutions designed to address unique urban challenges. For example, joint initiatives can lead to the development of open data platforms, enabling communities to actively participate in resilience planning.

3.7 Emerging Technologies

Several emerging technologies present potential avenues for enhancing urban resilience:

• Blockchain: can improve transparency and efficiency in resource distribution during emergencies, ensuring reliable information flow among stakeholders.
• Machine Learning: supports predictive analytics for recognizing patterns in urban behavior and environmental impacts, informing proactive urban policies.
• Augmented Reality (AR)/Virtual Reality (VR): can engage communities in resilience planning by visualizing potential impacts of climate change or disaster scenarios, fostering deeper understanding and involvement.

3.8 Related Topics

The intersection of technology, data integration, and urban resilience encompasses several significant themes, including sustainability, which underscores the need for environmentally friendly practices; economic development, emphasizing the importance of building economic resilience; and social cohesion, illustrating how community engagement can unify diverse groups towards common goals.

In summary, the role of technology in enhancing urban resilience is marked by its capacity to foster data-driven decision-making, promote adaptive strategies, and engage communities in sustainable practices. By embracing innovative collaborations and leveraging emerging technologies, cities can build more resilient and sustainable urban environments capable of thriving amid adversity.

Data-Driven Decision Making in Urban Planning

4.1 Definition and Context

Data-driven decision making in urban planning refers to the utilization of quantitative and qualitative data to inform the strategies, policies, and actions taken by urban planners and policymakers. This approach moves away from intuition-based decision-making, instead leveraging evidence obtained from various sources, including databases, surveys, geographic information systems (GIS), and social media analytics. The context of urbanization, characterized by rapid population growth and environmental challenges, necessitates a systematic and informed approach to managing urban growth, improving infrastructure, and enhancing the quality of life for residents. As cities face multifaceted issues such as congestion, pollution, climate change, and social inequity, data-driven strategies become increasingly crucial for sustainable urban development.

4.2 Key Components of Data-Driven Urban Planning

Data Collection

Effective data collection is the cornerstone of data-driven urban planning. With advancements in technology, a variety of innovative methods have emerged, such as:
– Remote Sensing: Using satellite imagery for land use analysis and monitoring environmental changes.
– Internet of Things (IoT) Sensors: Deploying sensors across urban infrastructure (e.g., traffic lights, waste bins) to gather real-time data on urban dynamics.
– Citizen Science: Empowering residents to contribute data through mobile applications, helping track local issues such as air quality and noise pollution.

Urban Management Functions

Data-driven approaches influence several core urban management functions, including:
– Resource Allocation: Utilizing data analytics to identify areas in need of infrastructural improvements or resource distribution.
– Service Delivery: Assessing and enhancing services such as waste management, public transportation, and emergency response planning through performance metrics.

Technology Integration

Integrating various technologies is crucial in enhancing data-driven decision-making. This involves:
– Geographic Information Systems (GIS): Mapping data visually to understand spatial relationships and patterns in urban contexts.
– Dashboards: Developing user-friendly interfaces for urban planners to monitor metrics and track progress toward goals.
– Predictive Analytics: Applying statistical models and machine learning to forecast future trends based on historical data.

4.3 Recent Trends

Recent trends in urban planning emphasize the instrumentation of cities—transforming urban spaces into smart cities through the deployment of connected devices and sensors that provide real-time data. This, combined with a transdisciplinary approach, encourages collaboration across disciplines (engineering, public health, environmental science) to create holistic and integrated urban planning solutions. These trends facilitate a more responsive and adaptive urban planning practice, which is crucial as cities grapple with challenges such as climate change and social inequities.

4.4 Applications and Implications

The implications of data-driven urban planning touch multiple facets of city management:

Service Delivery Improvements

By analyzing data from various sources, cities can design more effective services tailored to the needs of their populations. For instance, real-time traffic data can enhance public transit scheduling, leading to reduced wait times and improved user satisfaction.

Risk Modeling

Data can be leveraged to identify vulnerable areas within urban landscapes, enabling cities to model risks related to natural disasters and devise appropriate mitigation strategies. Risk modeling can particularly enhance emergency preparedness in the face of climate change.

Sustainable Urban Design

Data-driven insights can inform sustainable urban design practices by identifying the best locations for green spaces, energy-efficient buildings, and public transit networks, ultimately leading to improved environmental outcomes.

4.5 Impact of Big Data on Urban Policy

Big data profoundly influences urban policy by providing actionable insights for decision-making. Its impact includes:
– Policy Decisions: Data-driven insights assist policymakers in crafting targeted interventions that address specific urban challenges, such as homelessness, pollution, and transportation inefficiencies.
– Zoning Laws: Analyzing demographic and spatial data guides urban planners in revising zoning regulations to promote mixed-use development and affordable housing.
– Transportation Planning: Data analytics support the development of intelligent transport systems, optimizing traffic flow and enhancing public transit efficiency.

4.6 Tools and Technologies for Data Analysis

The following tools and technologies facilitate data analysis in urban planning:
– GIS Software: Essential for spatial analysis and mapping urban phenomena.
– Data Dashboards: Platforms that consolidate various data sources, allowing stakeholders to visualize key performance indicators and metrics.
– Predictive Analytics Tools: Software that employs algorithms to forecast urban trends, enabling proactive decision-making.

4.7 Community-Driven Data Initiatives

Engaging the community in data collection and analysis is pivotal to ensuring that urban planning decisions reflect local needs and priorities. Community-driven initiatives:
– Encourage Local Input: Crowdsourced data initiatives allow residents to voice concerns and contribute valuable insights about their neighborhoods.
– Build Trust: Transparency in data usage can foster trust between citizens and government, leading to better collaboration on urban challenges.

4.8 Related Fields

Data-driven urban planning intersects with several related fields, enhancing its effectiveness:
– Urban Analytics: The study of urban systems through advanced analytical techniques to identify patterns and trends.
– Smart Sustainable Cities: The integration of smart technologies into urban environments focusing on sustainability and improved quality of life.
– Data-Driven Urban Research: Collaborative research efforts employing data analytics to address complex urban issues.

---

In conclusion, the integration of data-driven decision-making into urban planning represents a transformative shift towards more sustainable, efficient, and resilient urban environments. As cities continue to evolve and face unprecedented challenges, the emphasis on data analytics and community engagement will be critical in shaping their futures. The collaboration among various stakeholders, along with the implementation of innovative technologies, will enable cities to adopt adaptive strategies that respond effectively to both present and future urban demands.

Conclusion

Discussion Points

Summary of the Importance of Integrating Data Analytics and Technology in Building Urban Resilience

The integration of data analytics and technology is fundamentally transforming our approach to urban resilience. By combining urban data analytics, advanced technological tools, and informed decision-making processes, cities can effectively fortify themselves against the multifaceted challenges posed by climate change and urbanization. By leveraging innovative data collection methods such as remote sensing and IoT sensors, urban planners are empowered to gain real-time insights into their environments, leading to more proactive and informed management strategies.

As highlighted throughout this discussion, the role of urban data analytics in fostering climate resilience cannot be overstated. It not only facilitates better resource allocation but also promotes community engagement and collaboration. For instance, when citizens are involved in data collection through citizen science initiatives, their contributions help create a richer narrative around urban dynamics, enhancing situational awareness and fostering a sense of ownership among the communities. This participatory approach not only increase the reliability of the data but also cultivates resilience in social fabric — a key element in thriving urban environments.

Moreover, technology acts as a catalyst, helping cities implement adaptive infrastructures that can swiftly respond to climatic shocks. The emergence of digital twins, machine learning applications, and data analytics tools are pivotal in operationalizing this approach. Such technologies not only optimize existing urban systems but also pave the way for innovation in urban design and service delivery, placing data at the forefront of urban planning and policy-making.

In summary, the integration of data analytics and technology is essential in building urban resilience. This comprehensive approach not only enhances the capacity of cities to withstand and recover from crises but also promotes sustainable growth, ultimately leading to more vibrant and livable urban environments.

Call to Action for Stakeholders to Collaborate and Innovate for Sustainable Urban Futures

As we stand at the nexus of advanced technology and urban development, there is an urgent need for collaboration among all stakeholders — government officials, urban planners, technology providers, and community members. To cultivate resilient urban futures, these entities must work together synergistically, pooling resources, knowledge, and expertise. This collective effort can harness the transformative potential of data analytics and technological innovations, ensuring that the solutions developed are comprehensive, inclusive, and tailored to the unique challenges faced by individual urban areas.

Stakeholders are encouraged to prioritize partnerships that promote open data initiatives, allowing for shared access to critical urban data. By creating platforms that facilitate dialogue and innovation, cities can co-create sustainable solutions that reflect the diverse needs of their residents. Furthermore, fostering an environment that encourages experimentation with emerging technologies — such as blockchain for transparency or augmented reality to visualize urban planning — will catalyze creative problem-solving and drive the evolution of resilient urban ecosystems.

Finally, investing in capacity-building programs that empower communities with the skills to utilize data for advocacy and decision-making is crucial. By equipping citizens with the tools they need to engage meaningfully in the urban planning process, we elevate the discourse around resilience and innovation.

In conclusion, the path to sustainable urban futures lies in our ability to converge expertise, technology, and community engagement. Let us heed this call to action, fostering partnerships that not only enhance resilience but also promote equitable urban development, ensuring that future generations inherit urban spaces that are both resilient and thriving.